Frigate vs blue iris vs nvr. Not used it but there's also Frigate.

Frigate vs blue iris vs nvr 13) easily upload video to ftp. I've never used Blue Iris and have zero issues with Frigate NVR. I think open source NVR software like Frigate is one or two updates away from me switching for home use. etan91011 n3wb. I’ve updated the instructions below to reflect the latest version since there were a ton of changes. It has a lot of user-friendly features, like detecting your URI based on camera IP. support is none existent with HIK so we need to replace. It's a shame as when zoneminder was set up right it was great, but it would always blow up and I got less and less interested in fixing it. Other Though since you already paid for Blue iris, you may want to keep that as your 24/7 NVR and for the outstanding webinterface. My favorite feature by far is the timeline view on the NVR. but i use the free free version of scrupted with some plugins so i can send my cameras to icloud and integrate with my phone (i pay for icloud rather than frigate) icloud syncs with my photos and runs ai detection on its own They both got both streams. I toyed around with enabling go2rtc with Frigate and it does work very well but I haven't yet gotten all my cameras configured properly. 0 is out 🎉 with AI acceleration on CPUs and GPU i replaced blue iris with frigate and ive been happy with it. Even Re: Blue iris vs dahua wizmind nvr vs frigate NVR plus a24/7 nvr Post by TimG » Fri Sep 27, 2024 5:13 pm Before anybody spends an hour trying to respond to this, it is a Home Assistant Reddit post and I believe it has been copied here by somebody else in The number of cameras are irrelevant to Blue Iris I'm amazed by what Frigate can do and with the cheap Google Coral AI thing. I finally made the switch to Blue Iris and am kicking myself for waiting so long. This is a fairly big deal when it comes to updates, as Windows doesn’t handle updates par Blue iris is my main security NVR while I use frigate for some automation stuff and tinkering. I'm normally pretty technical and like digging into these things but my spouse died which has me totally f'd up. I have over 20 blue iris machines running as smooth as butter. You are going to need a GPU based on your goals. Blue Iris records motions alerts and uploads them to my OneDrive account. If you want to scrub through timelines or things like that, you may find it a bit lacking. In the case of BlueIris all cameras would be attached to a PoE switch, and then the PC with BlueIris will be connected to the same switch using a single Cat6 cable. frigate works perfectly right now, I'm just wondering if there is something even better (but I'm only using the substream right now because there seem to be some problems in the network connection to my cams and I can't seem to get the 5MP feed from more than 1 cam at a time, even with the OEM hardware NVR). 12) if you have a matrix setup for live view where one camera is larger than others so you can see it better, you can set blue iris to display the camera that is detecting motion on the larger view. Reolink has their own app as well. Ive had the beta running for about a month now, and detection is I used to use a server running Blue Iris, and it performed very well. Most Reolink cameras are compatible between NVR’s (with some nuances, gotta read the fine print) and cameras are compatible with an array of recorders (like synology) and Blue Iris does have support for Intel and Intel + VPP, so if the ARC has those APIs, BI can take advantage of it. But there are plenty of stand alone NVRs. However I have both a RLN36 and a Frigate system. we recently bought a house and picked up 4 (2 packs of Amcrest 2-Pack UltraHD 4K (8MP) Outdoor Hikvision NVR vs Blue Iris Thread starter MadamImAdam; Start date Apr 22, 2020; Blue Iris 5 Discount! $62. Other great apps like Frigate NVR are Shinobi, Yawcam, Blue Iris and MotionEye. I'm just very curious on the ai capabilities of blue iris vs frigate with coral tpu. However, in recent months there seems to have been a lot of negativity, including with their server/authentication issues. Again looking for some real world how it works vs speculation. However, the per camera licensing cost is insane. 2 seconds, then Frigate via Home Assistant came in at 2. They’re hooked to a beastly computer (6-core E5-2620 with 128GB of ram) so I have no problem scaling up the shared memory area so ZM can do its thing. Share Sort by: Best. Wondering if anyone has used Frigate + a Google Coral as well as Code Project AI + a dedicated GPU with Blue Iris. If that doesn't suit you, our users have ranked more than 25 alternatives to Blue Iris and nine of them is open source so hopefully you can find a suitable replacement. Worst case, you can also fall back to DirectX VA2 or Direct3D11 VA. iSpy is famous for being the best completely free security software available, and despite the fact that It won’t cost you a dime, it’s a fairly expansive system. The biggest gap right now in my mind is Frigate's poor feature set for continuous recording, which seems like very basic functionality but ends up as a low priority for a lot of these "event-first" products An NVR is basically a computer that only does one function - for most, the software between what is on an NVR versus Blue Iris is night and day. For example, Frigate, ZoneMinder and iSpy are all alternatives to Blueiris and run under Linux. I already had a home server running with Plex so the additional cost for the server was zero. On the other hand, Blue Iris has a remote app. I do use Home Assistant and HomeKit and the integration with Scrypted is top notch. 265 profiles. Frigate vs MotionEye - Recommended NVR that supports network storage for continous recording . Stick with Frigate only. Considering the very limited supply of Coral USB Accelerator at this stage, only the Frigate NVR bundle kit is available online now. 4. For many users, Frigate has everything they need in an NVR. r/arlo. Recent commits have higher weight than older ones. I like the new "ai" feathures that are available. Although Blue Iris and NVRs share a lot Frigate vs scrypted Have anyone used those two over a longer period and made up any thoughts about pro and cons between them? The base price of frigate is free so thats a pro, but if you count the plus subscription (custom models), the frigate+ I think many users definition of a "full-fledged" NVR will be different. Still a lot of disconnects but not as many. Blue Iris Cloud - Cloud Storage / Backup . 264 and the resolution to 1920x1080 or 2MP. These are the relevant configs for reference-0. I used an LXC of Frigate, a VM of HAOS, and the Frigate-Proxy on the same system running ProxMox. I have no complaints about the software, and the app is very usable. To add, Reolink offers AI cameras. Although frigate can do some of what the camera can do, with a nicer mqtt interface. A lot of the threads I am reading just say "read the wiki," or "you'll like Blue Iris better," which honestly isn't really helpful. You need to look at each option's hardware requirements. However, I've seemed to notice theres an RTMP output but no m3u, ok I can probably work around this. Jan 4, 2022 10 2 Minnesota. I don't know what the bitrate is for 4k so you might want several hard drives in RAID 10 but that may be overkill. I rarely Reolink cameras with Blue Iris server. You have a few options if you want simplicity. Locked post. But Ken, is just one person and a small team, versus open source making improvements every day. I got my hands on two Reolink cameras RLC-522 & RLC-520 as well as the Reolink NVR RLN8-410. New Personally the only reason I can see using a Reolink NVR and Frigate NVR is if you wanted to maintain easy access to recordings for users on a dedicated device. It's unfortunate that it isn't available for Linux, as Windows is only useful as a desktop OS. I have blue Iris record 24/7 and frigate only records clips when triggered. Frigate also works great to just view your cameras. I am considering purchasing Blue Iris to manage and view my cameras from multiple brands in one place. I have Frigate and a coral Ai for object detection on a single camera which is at my front we have an HIK Vision NVR with two IP cameras attached. Search titles only By: Search Advanced search Search titles only IPCT+ Blue Iris Cloud Blue Iris Updates IPCT DDNS Focal Lens Calculator Hard Drive Space Calculator Hikvision PW Reset Tool IP Address Lookup Open Port Checker Speed Test Uptime Watchdog. I have a set of seven Reolink security cameras that I’ve used with Zoneminder for a long time. I need motion detection and ideally AI analysis to flat video to make finding incidents easier correting Menu. Home. I'm running Blue Iris on an i5 4590 with 8 gigs of ram and it. I used frigate for about 2 years before getting fed up with its lack of functionality and frankly poor integration with HA. One option I was considering was installing Frigate, but I am unsure how that setup would connect to Blue Iris for the AI and alerting portion, as there doesn't seem to be a direct connection between the two applications. The frigate interface isn't good EDIT 01-27-2020: Frigate 0. I'm trying to understand why a dedicated NVR would or would not be a better solution. Reactions: mat200. As far as I understand, Blue Iris is a £50 year subscription, so I'd consider switching to something running Linux and preferably containerised for ease of management (and it means 1 fewer Windows Server) I have tried to get frigate working, and I really want to like this, especially since it has tight integration with Home-assistant Here is a recent blog article: Frigate NVR Version 13 There is a Search. BI also introduced "Intel Beta" support (H. While most individuals can choose a security camera easily, the problem arises when selecting the best platform to manage them. Reply reply After comparing Frigate to BI over 3 days and realizing Frigate had no false positives and BI had a crap load of false negatives, I switched off the motion detection on BI and haven't looked back. Frigate is a pitiful excuse for an NVR. No audio playing in the livestream when viewing the cameras on the frigate ui. E. (Intel Quick Sync), you can enable it in Blue Iris 4 -> Options -> Cameras tab by setting "Hardware accelerated decode" to "Intel". 265 decoding). Agent DVR is described as 'New advanced video surveillance platform for Windows, Mac OS, Linux, Raspberry Pi and Docker. This one is more Look up frigate nvr. we have an HIK Vision NVR with two IP cameras attached. Blue Iris had been top of my list because it has been mentioned positively in several forums over a long time. Im goin to build new cam system for office. that would make it a full-blown NVR to match or surpass BlueIris. I moved from in-camera detection (HikVision) to Frigate and it eliminated 95% of false positives from things like birds, trees etc. General discussion about Blue Iris. Frigate vs CPAI . For Reolink NVR, you can view remote if the NVR is connected to the Internet. Unraid provides thousands (1889) of pre-built dockers, including Blue Iris, Frigate, Zoneminder , Shinobi, etc. NVR. Another problem with an NVR is people never buy one large enough. I made new-sub streams, added them to BI as dedicated cameras and just have Frigate pull the streams from BI. That'll depend on the settings/video stream quality, etc that you setup. Donate. Blue Iris is windows-only, consumed a lot of resources, and I'm not sure how well it would do as a server (I didn't try it long). I'm trying to decide between the dahua NVR and investing in a full Blue Iris setup. In most Blue Iris installations, your CPU is the limiting factor which determines how many cameras you can have. The best Frigate NVR alternative is ZoneMinder, which is both free and Open Source. I just added Blue Iris onto that server since it could easily handle it. Honestly I tried blue iris, and find synology Ss is miles ahead of it in As mentioned in the title I plan to use a PC instead of a dedicated NVR. Forums Frigate seems like one of the most promising new NVR/VMS products out there, but still lacks the feature-completeness to replace Blue Iris. 2 Coral (standard Frigate Coral setup) with a i5-7500 and averages 8ms: Different models on the same hardware change the inference speed, The built in Frigate OpenVino SSDLite MobileNet model I get average 12ms: Let’s jump right in and look at the pricing of these two security software systems. When I do make the switch I'll move from using UDM pro to using one of their devoted 4 bay NVRs. For lots of us running Blue Iris, we likely have way more than 4 cameras due to the 64-camera limit. I've read a variety of guides on set up and watched the Hook Ups videos. ly/3dwlGRgEbay Listing Dell Optiplex: https://eb ESP32 is a series of low cost, low power system on a chip microcontrollers with integrated Wi-Fi and dual-mode Bluetooth. just letting you know. Growth - month over month growth in stars. i ise both scrupted and frigate. Obviously their are reasons why I pick Blue Iris over other options. It's much faster and has a higher quality stream. 9 seconds, Ring Pro at 4. Hi all, and thank you for your patience if i ask obvious questions, and apologies if this isnt the right place for these questions. P. MadamImAdam Young grasshopper. the experience was sub par and the licencing is crazy beyond the free 2 cameras. I know Blue Iris is the ultimate goal, but at the moment for cost and speed to implement I'm wondering how much I'll miss out on going the NVR route. It makes no sense for developers to design for CPU alone anymore. 264 video and AAC audio will offer the most compatibility with all features of Frigate and Home Assistant. M. Reolink NVR can be expanded to 12TB. And SecuritySpy seems to do it on much larger image sizes on Mac M1 hardware - same thing - without a TPU needed. It was one of the first viable methods of getting generic ip cams into an Apple homekit setup, and they recently released an NVR plugin (beta still IIRC) that looks promising. My eyes are currently set on Blue Iris but with it being paid software, I'd hate for the license to randomly become invalid in a few years and require an internet connection to revalidate. 99. Any other option will likely mean you meed some kind of hardware infrastructure to NVR vs BlueIris vs BlueCherry Thread starter JuliusTheodore; Start date May 25, 2016; Blue Iris 5 Discount! $62. I also am using Frigate NVR with a Coral USB on a Linux machine, with Home Assistant to handle notifications. I get mixed messages online and can't afford to just buy a 3060 new machine Frigate is excellent, within the bounds of what it does. 12. Frigate still has a long way to go before it can replace BI for that. From what In my opinion blue iris doesn’t really fit with the rest of them as it is a full blown NVR with a ton of customization. The best Blue Iris alternative is ZoneMinder, which is both free and Open Source. Blue Iris has been around quite a bit longer, and is much more mature. The Reolink NVR was next with an average time of 2. Rotate is great for detection and blue Iris is great for storage and playback. Software NVR's are honestly not great when you compare to a device that is solely designed for this one task. Performance Comparison: Frigate NVR vs Scrypted. That's how I do it. New comments cannot be posted. 4, the Annke NVR at 5. For sure I could've saved Blue-Iris is a much more feature rich NVR and I would have gone with it if i dint go the Frigate route. IPCT Contributor. It really depends on if the NVR "reviewing footage" style features are valuable to you. So if it's a choice of putting an old desktop to use vs buying an NVR and being all set, blue iris isn't winning with subscription service at all. Used to use the blueiris integration although recently changed to frigate. NL-DUX October 26, 2022, 9:59am 37. C I didn’t know blue iris isn’t a NVR but a video management system. With that said, I do keep an NVR on my camera vlan as a backup to the blue Iris system. At this time, Bluecherry does not have a remote app Not used it but there's also Frigate. When comparing Frigate NVR to Scrypted, several factors come into play: Processing Speed: Frigate, especially with the Coral Accelerator, can achieve over 100 FPS, making it ideal for high-demand environments. iSpy is free, which gives it a slight edge over Blue Iris, which comes at a premium. BI versus NVR - There is a big debate here on which is better. I've never used Blue Iris or a standalone NVR, but I'm a software developer so If you are doing a macmini, wipe the OS and use ProxMox. Post by TimG » Fri Sep 27, 2024 5: Blue Iris is a lot more evolved and feature rich than the other NVRs mentioned so far. From what I've seen, people who have tried both an NVR and BI always highly recommend Blue Iris over an NVR. I especially like About NVR vs Blue Iris, Surveillance systems have become paramount for homeowners seeking to monitor their premises or business owners wanting to secure their workplaces. I don't know the lorex NVR, but my experience with NVRs is that their software is always lacking. Your camera's should be able to stream to both your hikvision NVR and frigate. I’ve ordered a coral to try with both Frigate and codeprojectAI. tldr; Just try it if you have the hardware and only need to use the 2 free licenses at most. I am hoping someone can give me specifics as to what Blue Iris would offer vs an NVR. Blue Iris seems more like full fledged NVR software. I blocked all web access to it (security reasons) and it is set to record continuously. Re: Blue iris vs dahua wizmind nvr vs frigate NVR plus a24/7 nvr Post by TimG » Fri Sep 27, 2024 5:13 pm Before anybody spends an hour trying to respond to this, it is a Home Assistant Reddit post and I believe it has been copied here by somebody else in Frigate is good for object detection, that’s about it. Integration: Frigate's seamless integration with Home Assistant provides a more iSpy and Blue Iris go toe to toe with each other in almost every single category. the iOS app is very clean and sharper looking than the BlueIris app, by far. Same I to frigate. H. I am confused which one to choose among the above said 3 NVR solutions. Or if your if you still want Windows and look at something like Milestone Xprotect Essentials or Express. I’m running scrypted to get my cameras into HomeKit and have blue iris running for 24/7 I find the apple home notifications Considering the very limited supply of Coral USB Accelerator at this stage, only the Frigate NVR bundle kit is available online now. I still use blue iris alongside frigate, with blueiris being my 24/7 NVR and frigate for everything else. Frigate for detection + notifications Hikvision for Blue iris vs dahua wizmind nvr vs frigate NVR plus a24/7 nvr. we need to be able to connect the cameras through the NVR to our Blue Iris vs 5 server. Toggle signature. 0. I personally have 9 cameras (mixture of indoor and outdoor) at the moment and that will likely expand to 12 or so by the end of the year. I tried viewing the camera / performance They offer full resolution for the main stream and a 720p substream for frigate’s detection and inferencing. View attachment 164464 View attachment 164466 All the VM functionality is straightforward with templates I'd rather donate money to open source than buy anything from Blue Iris. Jan 17, 2017 15,388 25,937. What is blue iris deep analysis? Thanks everyone Share Sort by: Top. Blue Iris is a bit clunky like zoneminder Reply reply Hi - I've recently set up Blue Iris with Deepstack for Ai, I've got 5 cameras set up - a couple cheap Amcrests and 3 Dahua/Loryta cams I've gotten here or from Empire Tech. I don't see how I am locked into using Blue Iris. The only thing I miss when using Frigate is UI3. The UI of the NVR plugin also seems fairly well thought out (similar to Blue Iris has configuration specs on their site. I find Blue Iris to be awesome and the mobile app is very good. There's a cool dahua feature acupick which I'm not sure is easily or affordably available with I used frigate primarily to run object recognition on the substreams and trigger events (even trigger blue iris alerts), while I used blue iris webinterface as "nvr" and even feed live video in home assistant front end through a webpage card. I use my Hikvision NVR's app for live streaming. There are eight alternatives to Agent DVR for a variety of platforms, including Linux, iPhone, iPad, Self-Hosted Shinobi and Blue Iris are both fantastic. Open comment sort options. Frigate is a very close second and getting there. I want motion alerts and other functionality to be as tightly integrated to HE. I’ve been running Frigate in Docker successfully on a Synology for some time now I suggest you use Blue Iris if you have never used a program like this before, and even more so if you have no linux experience. Just hang a big drive somewhere on your network and point to it. Blue Iris vs. Someone here posted a while ago that they are using Frigate for notifications, and Blue Iris for 24x7 video recording. . Currently have a monitor streaming 6 cameras 24/7 with frigate hooked into blue iris and it works great. Frigate is relatively easy to do backups with, but you would need a PC I'm just very curious on the ai capabilities of blue iris vs frigate with coral tpu. Top Blue Iris and sighthound are the two best software nvr solutions in my opinion. Blue Iris is the gold standard but it requires Windows and cost $70. Im certainly going to buy few cameras, but im wondering about nvr. I get mixed messages online and can't afford to just buy a 3060 new machine just to test n find out it wasn't needed when a coral tpu could have saved me 600. Blue Iris and Frigate together are an excellent match. are there any recommendation out there on a setup for this configuration? the NVR provides HDMI output to a Monitor at a distant location without the Viseron 2. Blue Iris may have crashed but I honestly can't remember. The three most popular security camera DIY NVRs are ZoneMinder, iSpy, and Blue Iris. Today I installed frigate and while I had an initial issue setting up, I was up and running. It supports Coral, doorbells, two-way audio, and is able to expose the cameras to HomeKit Which AI person detection NVR is the best? Lets Find out!Blue Iris Build:Blue Iris NVR Software: https://bit. Best. Frigate is great for looking at recognition events, and the image recognition is great. Both of my computers would run my 10x4 MP cameras(IPC-HDW5442TM-ASE ) recording 24/7 at 15% to 20% cpu usage. i am new to the Home Automation world and subsequently new to Blue Iris. I don't have a TPU as yes but hoping I will shortly. Videos go to frigate first which rebroadcasts the streams to blue Iris. Frigate works much better with newer reolink cameras that are setup with the below options: If available, recommended settings are: On, fluency first this sets the camera to CBR Cameras connected via a Reolink NVR can be connected with the http stream, use It is interesting how your RPi4 USB Coral is 17ms, At the moment I have a M. Share your videos with friends, family, and the world A NVR does not provide info data to a third party as storage is self contained. They also offer in-camera detection (movement, person, vehicle) and various rules like tripwire, direction detection, zones, etc. I moved from Frigate to Blue Iris running on a windows vm and it’s been super reliable and easy to use. but i love blue iris. Blue Iris is the one which comes with a cost and of which everyone speaks high but I am still not sure what additional value it gives. The unofficial subreddit for Arlo's products and services. At some point, there won’t be any reason for me to Not used a dedicated NVR before. I already have 24 poe+ switch, so the cost was NVR ($600) vs mini PC+BI ($700). You get a lot of fine tuning options with Frigate whereas code project is a rudimentary implementation of where camera AI was about 5 years ago - you send it images with no ability to improve false positives or view However, as an NVR its pretty basic. Viseron is a self-hosted NVR deployed via Docker, which utilizes machine learning to detect objects and start recordings. If so, any particular pros, cons, interesting things you've discovered when using them? I use BI as my primary NVR. 265, and they support a limited number of H. I saved about 100W by ditching the PC. Other A lot of blue iris crashes are related to Intel drivers, there are some memory leaks. I've got things working more or less, though I'm sure I'm far from optimized. I don’t even need to hook Blue iris up to HA, it does everything inside itself. The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. The ESP32 series employs either a Tensilica Xtensa LX6, Xtensa LX7 or a RiscV processor, and both dual-core and single-core variations are available. Right off the bat, the benefit of Frigate is that it can be installed on Docker which runs on various devices. At one point I began writing my own nvr but didn't find enough time to get too far with it. I've seen it referred to a fair bit in posts about object recognition, AI detection etc. Adding the NVR to Blue Iris and then using Blue Iris features for the individual NVR cameras (and to determine where the recordings go) is fairly simple to do and provides the best of both worlds. Nov 9, 2022 #11 I am looking for a good Blue iris alternative. I'm gonna have to install this There are more than 25 alternatives to Blue Iris for a variety of platforms, including Windows, Linux, Android, iPhone and iPad apps. Cameras configured to output H. I run unifi protect along with Frigate. i use frigate woth google coral usbs for detection locally. 4 HTTP config. Remember that each camera video encoding must be set to H. Does Facial Recognition work? I talk through my experience using Double-Take, Deepstack, and CompreFace with the Frigate NVR. The best I’ve found is Frigate + Home Assistant. Blue Iris, there’s a Mac one called SecuritySpy that works well with Apple Silicon, and Scrypted NVR is a new up and coming option. Not New to frigate and impressed with its capabilities with regards to object detection. I actually currently run both, but motion detection is done entirely There are more than 10 alternatives to Frigate NVR for a variety of platforms, including Linux, Self-Hosted, Windows, Mac and Android apps. There isnt any great local AI features built in, it normally triggers motion based on "motion detection" (that would be considered I have them both setup (Scrypted and Frigate NVR) and my HKSV works fine. NVR records 24/7. The reason was simply that the server used far more power than the NVR did. I have no need to run blue iris or any other software other than Frigate for my cameras. I'm currently using dlandon's Zoneminder docker for a general NVR but I'm also using blakeblackshear's Frigate Person/object detection is just about instantaneous with the Coral and Frigate. But when it comes to the fundamentals, like streaming quality, Blue Iris does reign supreme over iSpy. License plate detection is supported as a label that is detected, license plate reading will need to be done via an ALPR software like Blue Iris RTSP Cameras In both cases using the http stream is recommended. Blue Iris excels at dealing with multiple streams so it can do continuous recording on the substream and then when it alerts, it can What about NVIDIA on an x86 platform. Better than anything I’ve seen. I have a background in IT (mostly storage server rack hardware like NetApp). Blue iris vs dahua wizmind nvr vs frigate NVR plus a24/7 nvr. I do use blue Iris myself. Having the Reolink NVR always recording as its own separate system along side Blue-Iris or I've been running Scrypted NVR for several months now and to be honest, it's quite an impressive NVR solution with object detection built in. Ask questions, share insights, and learn more from your fellow home security community So then I switched to Blue Iris. well I did try a Synology out. Blue iris as hik vision nvr replacement ? Hello. Supposed to be quite good. Re: Blue iris vs dahua wizmind nvr vs frigate NVR plus a24/7 nvr Post by TimG » Fri Sep 27, 2024 5:13 pm Before anybody spends an hour trying to respond to this, it is a Home Assistant Reddit post and I believe it has been copied here by somebody else in Blue Iris uses a lot of CPU time. TLDR: Buy a proper dedicated NVR and never lookback at the mess that is software NVR's Frigate NVR 0. Frigate is super lightweight, it's been rock solid, and works so well in my experience. I'm about 80% sure i'll stay with it. As you will see in my post on your other thread, an The best open source alternative to Blue Iris is ZoneMinder. It doesn’t. I'm currently doing up an old countryside house, and wish to install a self-hosted security camera setup. Agent has a unified user interface that runs on all modern computers, mobile devices and even Virtual Reality' and is an app. I found Scrypted NVR is another alternative worth looking at. Now, what we have in our midst are two diagonally opposite services made to serve the same purpose: Monitor and Control Surveillance equipment. With 5 cameras on my system, Blue Iris takes up a constant 20% CPU running as a service. Frigate's recommended config, but with Reolink's default camera stream settings. AI is built into the camera and will work with most any NVR. Let's Discuss. With that said, if your cameras are overly sensitive, it could cause I actually just use the RTSP feed from the NVR into HA. Here is the search tool of all the NVR versus BI comparisons: blue iris vs nvr ip cam site:ipcamtalk. 8. So the seconds waiting for Blue Iris to switch to the main stream, or to start recording, are . edit: oh it's a 6c12t cpu and your cameras is 5mp, that cpu probably handle it, i dedicate 14 threads for 4 cameras and normally the cpu usage is between 20-30% with some peaks (40%) when detecting movements but my cameras are 1080p I use Blue Iris in a virtual CodeProject AI has better models out-of-the-box. I have 5 (could expand to 6-7 in the near future) outdoor cams and 4 indoor cams plus a doorbell cam. I happened to come across scrypted on HA as NVR today and would like to know the pro/cons comparing to frigate. But I actually use frigate to trigger alerts in blue iris, so I can use Blue Iris to review events and scrub time lines and the like. At the moment I’m still using Blue Iris with an Nvidia Jetson and Deepstack, very similar to Coral, for low cost AI object detection. the key is using a quality machine dedicated to the vms. So if you go with a pc/Blue iris i would suggest a i7 7th gen or newer just for the Blue Iris is going to give you a better experience overall. Apr 22, 2020 #1 Hello all. By default, Frigate uses some demo ML models from Google that aren't built for production use cases, and you need the paid version of Frigate ($5/month) to get access to better models, which ends up more expensive than Blue Iris. The Blue Iris VMS - And Local AI to detect "person" or other objects Blue Iris is a normal "dumb" NVR/VMS software that records several camera RTSP streams and present it to an API and a number of user interfaces. Frigate has crashed a few times with Python errors, but without anything to reference I don't know if this is a Frigate thing or a Reolink thing?? I'm still running 0. 0 - Self-hosted, local only NVR and AI Computer Vision software. Both of my cameras immediately were showing which is wonderful. A MQTT broker. Frigate NVR has just been mentioned in the forum section above this "Pics and Videos". Blue Iris is not a free service. Anyway, I’ve run it with dlandon’s object detection docker and recently he deprecated the docker image I was using so First, if you are only interested in event recordings, stick with Frigate, Scrypted NVR is 24/7 with event scrubbing. I personally feed my Reolink DVR into a Blue Iris NVR for AI detection with Sentry. Blue Iris Cloud - Cloud Storage / Backup I understand Blue Iris requires you to remote in via other means, such as VNC, etc. Lefty Posts: 2 Joined: Mon Jan 06, 2020 4:23 pm. there is a difference between license plate detection and reading. Frigate+blue Iris is the combo I’ve seen which is why I just bought a coral TPU. What I’m struggling with is Blue Iris seems to do AI with less demand than Frigate (no TPU needed). 2 posts • Page 1 of 1. What I noticed is that in the case of a PoE NVR, all cameras are attached directly to the NVR. I use the NVR’s apps and web interface to pull out specific recordings. If your camera has good hardware motion detection, then Scrypted will use that instead of software detection, which takes a massive load off your processor. I do find BI to be the better NVR, though, so I use Frigate I've been interested in trying out Scrypted DVR but the $10/camera and only 4 cameras is my limitation. As such, it is extremely important to optimize your configuration to ensure you can get the most out of your system while consuming the least Blue Iris options for AI motion detection are the best I've seen so far, so I keep it running, but to be honest, UniFi isn't far behind. NVRs are convenient but restrict you to one camera brand, tend to get out dated due to lack of support, lack features and adjustments, and normally have poor mobile apps. Need a recommendation between frigate and Scrypted . The other software you could look at is Frigate, especially if you want to use your cameras with home automation. Top. But Blue Iris and frigate seen to have different purposes. What are the actual differences between Blue Iris and a Dahua NVR? Is the Dahua NVR really unstable or doesn’t work good at all with motion events, etc? mat200. 3 and then Synology Surveillance Station consistently took around 26 I extensively tested 8 network video recorders from Reolink, Annke, Synology, Frigate, Blue Iris, UniFi Protect, Lorex, and Ring to figure out which one was Blue Iris is great, but if you can float the bill I will always recommend Scrypted from now on. It fails in all other categories and it’s pretty bad without a coral usb. As you may guess I will set these things up and I will compare the cameras, but that is not enough for me and I will also try to add them in Blue Iris I run two Reolink cameras with Blue Iris and they work fine. NVR5x-I, Domes, Mini domes, Mini PTZs, Thermal, Panoramic, fixed turrets and NKB1000. There's a few Dockers you can run: Shinobi, motion eye, frigate. Support Have been using Synology NAS with surveillance station for a while. I liked the developers, iconnor and pliable the latter did zmninja and object detection. However, I did switch to a Hikvision NVR in the end. Reply reply I've been testing Scrypted NVR mainly due to its client-side interface that looks very similar to a consumer grade camera system like Unifi protect and Google with the nice scrolling seeing thumbnails very quickly. 4 posts • Page 1 of 1. I use blue iris for continuous recording and backup recording of Today on the hookup we’re going to take a detailed look at the most popular NVR options from Synology, Reolink, UniFi, Lorex, Annke, Frigate, Blue Iris, and Ring and I’m going to test out 10 key features to help you figure out which, if any, of I can slowly save for stuff but I also don't want a full time job managing everything. Stars - the number of stars that a project has on GitHub. Check out Blue Iris - you will need a spare Windows 10 box, but it very inexpensive for what you get. So looking to switch to one of the open source solutions thats well integrated with HASS. Will be setting up some time next week. Remember that you can run more than one. Reolink's own NVR application appeared to be decent with no brainer remote viewing and app integration. If you want a complete system and cost is another factor I really like reolinks systems. It’s been running 24/7 for about two years now. I also setup an AWS S3 bucket as a mount in my server for screenshots and recordings from frigate so I have an additional source. Activity is a relative number indicating how actively a project is being developed. Additional comment actions. For ease of use i would go with a nvr every time. Before transitioning to BI I was using their nvr An instance of Frigate. Hello all, i'd love to take up some of you guys on your recommendations and offers to share your systems/setup. It is a web front end for the motion daemon. To secure one of their software packages requires a one-time payment. 3, Blue Iris at 8. This is because my cameras are hard-wired to a totally different network that only BI can access (via another NIC). Still works great! EDIT 12-15-2020: I just noticed that Frigate has a If you mean RTSP/ONVIF cameras as input, NVR and detection as output, there’s certainly alternatives. May 2, 2019 #5 sofakng said: Anyways I’m looking for an NVR that will work with all my cameras, including wifi Hikvision doorbell, multiple Amcrest POE and wireless cams, and Dahua POE cams. I used frigate primarily to run object recognition on the substreams and trigger events (even trigger blue iris alerts), while I used blue iris webinterface as "nvr" and even feed live video in home assistant front end through a webpage card. NVR: A Comparison. Frigate's integration with HA is easier imo since Frigate was built with HA in mind. including on the NVR and via web. If you're recording straight to disk without transcoding you don't need much in the way of CPU power. Here's a more detailed comparison of the products: Looking for CCTV/NVR recommendation (Frigate, Shinobi, iSpy, BlueIris, Zoneminder, etc) Blue Iris probably seems like the most obvious answer (especially since our whole setup is Amcrest at this point), but I'm not huge on spinning up a Windows VM just for BI, and I've never loved Amcrest Surveillance Pro, so part of me wants to try another Depends of NVR but you probably can use frigate getting the stream from the NVR. So eventually, I'll be comfortable switching over fully. At first I thought it was much better, and it was. I had two older 8 TB drives sitting on a I have a Blue Iris + NVR setup. 2, UniFi Protect at 5. Two way audio is not going to work the way you want it, its half duplex like a walkie talkiealso no hikvision outdoor cameras have a speaker - you would need to get a camera with an audio out and add an amplifier + a speaker and a powered mic if there is no built in mic. I got here because Blue Iris it seemed like a decent system. More posts you may like r/arlo. I'll start with my problems; My NVR (7608NI-E2) displays event tags on playback when directly operating the NVR. FFmpeg is used on a professional level for all kinds of video distribution, so don't think that's the reason Shinobi isn't on the level of Hi all, and thank you for your patience if i ask obvious questions, and apologies if this isnt the right place for these questions. It also uses deepstack for its smart detection. anthonyacosta Posts: 1 Joined: Fri Sep 27, 2024 7:15 am. Additionally, if you're in a single ecosystem (or planning one) consider a company NVR. You may not want to discount getting a packaged system with a built in NVR. 0 has been released. We will open the sale of the Coral USB Accelerator when the supply is back to normal. Frigate should be more widely considered the class leader. My cameras do at least 4 substreams and 3 main streams, possibly more, but thats what I tested. Top 9% Rank by size . It took a while to get it set up, but it's very accurate, and I actually like the user interface. You mentioned MotionEyeOS but MotionEye in docker is a great and simple NVR tool as well. com - Google Search Hey I use both. Not sure I can offer a fair comparison as I only touched Blue iris years ago but have been using Surveillance Station for many years now. I use it to record one camera 24/7 low res and monitor two cams for motion on low res but capture I’ll give you an in depth look at UniFi Protect, Reolink’s RLK8 NVR and Blue Iris with Deep Stack AI, and we’ll figure out if paying 5 times the price for the UniFi system, gets you 5 times the performance. I would not have upgraded if i didn't find a computer on ebay for only $250. MOTIONEYE NVR PAN/TILT: motionEye is a web based NVR (Network Video Recorder). Find what works for you, and good The setup processes for Frigate and Blue Iris are entirely different, as Frigate runs on Docker and Blue Iris is a Windows application. Blue iris requires Windows, which is an additional expense. Need advice migrating from BlueIris to Frigate Curious if anyone has given Scrypted NVR a shot. I liked blue iris but the lack of a linux client killed it for me. I can run frigate easily on the NUC hosting HA as I bought the Coral TPU coprocessor. The blueiris integration in HACS works great for this and doesn’t have this problem. 265 has better compression but less compatibility, as only Chrome 108+, Safari, and Edge can play H. I have a separate 4TB drive installed for 24/7 recordings. Current security camera tech is I am trying to decide between buying an NVR vs a PC with BlueIris. are there any recommendation out there on a setup for this configuration? the NVR provides HDMI output to a Monitor at a distant location without the so true hd space is cheap but the hikvision h265+, made there 4k 2385s run a lot easier on the 7600 series nvr The issue with this is that Blue Iris uses the Keyframes to trigger recording and to switch from the substream to the main stream. Either way, you can just try it. I like how small the video clips are and how it archives them. Reply reply More replies More replies. are there any recommendation out there on a setup for this configuration? the NVR provides HDMI output to a Monitor at a distant location without the Had the same issue with rtsp. Blue iris adds lots of function over an NVR. as for a NAS. I run mine in Unraid as a docker You will need to expose your cameras to Frigate. I've read that some cameras don't play well with either Blue Iris and/or Frigate. I tried Frigate and switched to the Reolink NVR and reolink_dev integration and have been thrilled with it so far. Oct 20, 2015 65 9. It's either GPU of something specialized like Coral TPU. If you use P2P for the NVR to get push notifications, then yes it is talking to servers you have no control over. tkd iepeno eqgaqno gjv qncxx nxuda zpbr meefkrzb ewapwpfz onno